Everyone walked away from Tuesday night’s College Football Playoff rankings show asking one question: What?

Michigan came in at No. 6 in this week’s Top 25, followed by Michigan State in the No. 7 spot. This comes 10 days after the Spartans defeated the Wolverines in East Lansing 37-33.

It appears that head-to-head results only matter for certain teams (Oregon-Ohio State) and not many others. The reasoning provided by College Football Playoff selection committee chairman Gary Barta didn’t provide much clarity, either.

Apparently, the committee views Michigan as “the more complete team” compared to Michigan State. Why play the games, right?

Twitter was ablaze with reaction from the committee’s decision to slot Jim Harbaugh’s team over Mel Tucker’s. Here are some of the best responses from Tuesday night: