Skip to content

Ad Disclosure


College Football

2019 NFL Draft: How every first-round pick was rated as a high school recruit

Dustin Schutte

By Dustin Schutte

Published:


Are recruiting rankings all they’re cracked up to be?

That’s a big question as it pertains to college football. Some coaches want to bring in as many of the top-ranked recruits as possible. Programs like Alabama, Clemson and Ohio State welcome a flood of four- and five-star recruits through their doors. Meanwhile, other schools like Iowa, Washington State and Wisconsin are more concerned with having a type of player.

So, the big question is this: is there a right way to recruit?

Well, based on the results from the 2019 NFL Draft, it may not matter as much as you’d think. Although, based on the College Football Playoff results over the last five years, it’s pretty darn important to have at least a few four- and five-star guys on the roster.

But as far as recruiting rankings relating to the NFL, there doesn’t seem to be as much of a correlation. On Thursday night, 32 players realized their dream of playing football at the professional level, being selected in the first round of the NFL Draft. And you might be surprised to know that former three-star prospects were in the majority of the selections.

Here’s a quick breakdown of the first-round picks by high school recruiting star rankings:

  • 5-star: 8
  • 4-star: 10
  • 3-star: 11
  • 2-star: 1
  • NR: 2

While 18 of the 32 players drafted were ranked as a four- or five-star player in high school, there were 11 players who entered college as a three-star prospect. There was also one two-star recruit and two players who were not rated by 247Sports.

Here’s a look at every first-round draft pick from Thursday night’s NFL Draft and the star ranking he received as a high school recruit. Enjoy:

Pick Team Player Position College Stars
1 Arizona Cardinals    Kyler Murray    QB    Oklahoma *****
2 San Francisco 49ers    Nick Bosa    DE    Ohio State *****
3 New York Jets  Quinnen Williams    DT    Alabama ****
4 Oakland Raiders    Clelin Ferrell    DE    Clemson ****
5 Tampa Bay Buccaneers    Devin White    LB    LSU ****
6 New York Giants    Daniel Jones    QB    Duke NR
7 Jacksonville Jaguars    Josh Allen    DE    Kentucky **
8 Detroit Lions    T.J. Hockenson    TE    Iowa ***
9 Buffalo Bills    Ed Oliver    DT    Houston *****
10 Pittsburgh Steelers    Devin Bush    LB    Michigan ****
11 Cincinnati Bengals    Jonah Williams    OT    Alabama *****
12 Green Bay Packers    Rashan Gary    DE    Michigan *****
13 Miami Dolphins    Christian Wilkins    DT    Clemson *****
14 Atlanta Falcons    Chris Lindstrom    OG    Boston College ***
15 Washington Redskins    Dwayne Haskins    QB    Ohio State ****
16 Carolina Panthers    Brian Burns    LB    Florida State ****
17 New York Giants    Dexter Lawrence    DT    Clemson *****
18 Minnesota Vikings    Garrett Bradbury    OC    NC State ***
19 Tennessee Titans    Jeffery Simmons    DT  Mississippi State *****
20 Denver Broncos    Noah Fant    TE    Iowa ***
21 Green Bay Packers    Darnell Savage    S    Maryland ***
22 Philadelphia Eagles    Andre Dillard    OT Washington State ***
23 Houston Texans    Tytus Howard    OT    Alabama State NR
24 Oakland Raiders    Josh Jacobs    RB    Alabama ***
25 Baltimore Ravens    Marquise Brown    WR    Oklahoma ****
26 Washington Redskins    Montez Sweat    LB    Mississippi Sate ***
27 Oakland Raiders   Johnathan Abram    S    Mississippi State ***
28 Los Angeles Chargers    Jerry Tillery    DT    Notre Dame ****
29 Seattle Seahawks    L.J. Collier    DE     TCU ***
30 New York Giants    Deandre Baker    CB    Georgia ***
31 Atlanta Falcons    Kaleb McGary    OT    Washington ****
32 New England Patriots    N’Keal Harry    WR    Arizona State ****
Dustin Schutte

Dustin grew up in the heart of Big Ten country and has been in sports media since 2010. He has been covering Big Ten football since 2014. You can follow him on Twitter: @SchutteCFB