The College GameDay crew was live from South Bend Saturday morning to preview the elite Ohio State vs. Notre Dame showdown in Week 4. That primetime matchup caps what should be a brilliant day of football with 6 total top-25 matchups in store.

When it came time to pick the winner in the game, the crew was decidedly split. Desmond Howard and Kirk Herbstreit led off with some unsurprising selections while guest picker Vince Vaughn, Pat McAfee and Lee Croso followed.

Desmond Howard: Notre Dame. “They’re hungry and excited and which QB do you trust more? Gotta be Sam Hartman, right?”

Kirk Herbstreit: Ohio State. “The approach and the attitude is big.”

Pat McAfee: Notre Dame. “I’m hypnotized by the hype… Give me Sam Hartman, Estime and Notre Dame.”

Vince Vaughn: Notre Dame. “You can’t talk about football without talking about the great state of Ohio… That being said, I played for Notre Dame. And if I had half the heart of Rudy, I’d be an All-American. The Irish will prevail.”

Lee Corso: Ohio State while noting he wins around 60% of the time when he dons the Brutus headgear.